
All three of these Korean-made players are available now in the U.S.. Each has been around long enough to benefit from a few firmware updates. All are pocketable touchscreen players with 480 x 272 resolution. All support FLASH games and apps. All have Bluetooth. These are easily the showstoppers from each company this year, and the competition between them is good news for consumers. Here we'll take a look at the Samsung P3, Cowon S9, and iriver SPINN.
I'll compare them for aesthetic design, hardware details, format support, usability, price, and overall satisfaction as personal media players. I've had all three for some time now, and done exhaustive testing of each. Scores will be explained in each category and will be from 1 to ?, with the higher number being the better score. You'll have your own priorities for the player you own, so don't let the final tally dissuade you from your favorite.
Aesthetic Design. I'm a furniture and product designer, and greatly appreciate the looks of a player. Players that go beyond being visual "knock-offs" and seek new aesthetic territory get my vote. These players all caught my eye before getting further attention from me. My guess is that they've caught your attention too. I've rated them as I see them. Click on each to see their manufacturer support pages and the relative "press" given to the aesthetic design of each.
Simply beautiful from every point of view.
Original Spindle control breaks away from the pack.
Minor improvement over the P2. No iPod clone.
Hardware Details. These days a player has to be more than just a touchscreen. The
P3 and
SPINN both have haptic (vibration) feedback when you touch them. The
S9 and
SPINN are AMOLED (beautiful!) screens compared to the
P3's backlit LCD. All have Bluetooth but the
P3 has far greater profile support than the other two. They all have external volume buttons. The
SPINN and
S9 offer external Pause/Play and track Fwd/Back. The
P3 has a speaker. The
SPINN and the
S9 have 3.3" screens to the
P3's 3-incher, but the
S9's screen supports a greater color range than the
SPINN. Each device gets a point for any feature all three don't have.
Samsung P3 ·
5 Points: Haptic + BT Phone pairing + BT File transfer + BT game play + Speaker.
iriver SPINN ·
4 Points: Haptic + Spindle controls + AMOLED + 3.3" screen.
Cowon S9 ·
7 Points: G-Sensor + Track/Play/Pause controls + AMOLED + 3.3" screen +
more colors + LineIn + TVout.
Format Support. This is simply another counting comparison. If you're coming from an iPod then AAC and MP4 media playback will be worth more to you than OGG or FLAC or WMV. Yet each
codec has value to somebody. As such each audio and video and photo codec supported gets one point. Click on each to go to their specifications page.
iriver SPINN ·
13 Points: MP3, WMA, OGG, FLAC, ASF, APE for music.
MP4, WMV, XVID for video. JPG, GIF, BMP, PNG for photos.
Cowon S9 ·
10 Points: MP3, WMA, FLAC, OGG, WAV, APE for music. AVI, WMV, ASF for video. JPG for photos.
Samsung P3 ·
13 Points: MP3, WMA, OGG, WAV, AAC, FLAC for Music. JPG, BMP, PNG for photos. SWF, WMV, H.264, MPEG for videos.
Usability. How easy is it to turn on the player, find the song you want to play, and start listening to it? The P3 will resume on the page it was on when you last turned it off. It's also got a touch interface that really takes advantage of the hardware's potential. With the S9 one tap on the Music icon goes directly into the media player, yet makes you "back up" to pick a song to play. The SPINN lets you look for and select a song without touching the screen, yet doesn't let you control it completely with touches on the screen. For this comparison 5 songs are chosen among all the common songs each player contains. The average number of taps/click/spins/strokes it takes to begin playing each song will be part of that player's score, with
low score winning. The songs were all from different albums, and spread across the alphabet. From
Boof by Tony Remy to
Unwritten by Natasha Bedingfield.
Cowon S9 · 2 Points: 5.4 average.
Samsung P3 · 1 Point: 6.2 average
iriver SPINN · 0 Points: 7.2 average
The other part will be a boot-up value. Using my stopwatch each device will be timed from when the power switch is pressed/slid to when an icon can be tapped on. The quickest device gets 2 points. Second place gets 1, and last place gets 0 additional points.
Samsung P3 · 0 Points:
From OFF = 11.90 seconds. From SLEEP = 2.70 seconds. (14.60)
iriver SPINN · 1 Point:
From OFF = 7.71 seconds. From SLEEP = 1.18 seconds. (8.89)
Cowon S9 · 2 Points:
From OFF = 6.09 seconds. From SLEEP = 1.52 seconds. (7.61)
Price. The price has fallen on both the S9 and SPINN since they first came out. The P3 is the latest to arrive, yet it's MSRP is competitive with the other's current prices. The SPINN doesn't come in a 16gb version, so these prices are all for the 8gb versions of each device. The P3 is a bargain here, with 16gb models still under $200. There is more cost involved with the AMOLED screens that the S9 and SPINN use, but their prices have crept down since the P3 was released, and may come down more. Lowest price gets the highest score.
Samsung YP-P3 8gb ·
2 Points:
$149.99 iriver SPINN 8gb ·
1 Point:
$159.00* normally still $199.
Overall satisfaction. This part is purely subjective. I hate the SPINN's user interface. I love the efficiency of the P3's UI. The one I most want to hold in my hand is the Cowon S9. All three sound great once you get to your music and start listening. The S9's amazing battery life reduces that annoying need to charge these players periodically. Cowon has a U.S. based retail arm (
jetmall.net) that make is easy to find cables and other accessories. The P3's extended bluetooth capabilities exceed those of the other two, but in practive I don't use them much. That little speaker the P3 has makes it easy to check sounds when your headphones are out of reach. Widgets are generally eye-candy and have little to do with media play on the P3 or S9, yet some provide easy access to system settings. No widgets on the SPINN. What pushes the S9 over the edge is it's support for
video-output and
line-in recording. Watching videos on that 3.3" AMOLED screen is satisfying, but watching them on a 40" HDTV is easier on the eyes. Neither the P3 or SPINN allow this. For these reasons I score them:
Cowon S9 · 4 Points.
Samsung P3 · 3 Points.
iriver SPINN · 0 Points.
Totals. Simple addition. The Cowon S9 wins!
S9 = 30 Points. P3 = 27.5 Points. SPINN = 23.5 Points.
Your personal satisfaction may vary, but online forum activity seems to follow these results. The
busiest forum (of these three devices) is the
Cowon S9 forum at anythingbutipod.com. Their
Samsung P3 forum is most recent to the game, yet is building in activity as more people get them. It's hard to find anyone checking their
SPINN forum these days. The one I pick up most often is the S9, yet I'll take the P3 with me to show off it's capablities to friends. I think 99% would be happy with either, and the SPINN will satisfy anyone who hasn't seen an S9 or P3. ;·)
4D.
What do YOU think? Leave a Comment.
If you enjoy my blog, please consider clicking on an Ad or two. Thanks!